|
|
|
|
|
|
|
History of Code Development
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In March 1996, Alternative Link began compiling terminology to describe alternative
medicine, nursing and other integrative healthcare interventions.
The Company first established criteria for evaluating the legitimacy of each term.
For example, to be designated as official terminology, each term needed to represent
the services or supplies delivered by at least one type of CAM practitioner that 1)
provided healthcare services, 2) held a license as a healthcare provider in at least
one state, and 3) had access to malpractice insurance for the licensed healthcare
practice. Each term also needed to be reviewed and accepted by a predefined number of SMEs.
Alternative Link hired an SME on holistic medicine to identify terms that could be
considered candidates for official terminology. The SME queried nationally certified
schools and alternative medicine clinics to secure terms used in academic institutions
and private practice.
The SME provided information from the following sources:
-
Bastyr University, Natural Health Clinic
-
Emperor's College of Traditional Oriental Medicine
-
Logan College of Chiropractic
-
Minnesota Institute of Acupuncture and Herbal Studies
-
National College of Chiropractic
-
National College of Naturopathic Medicine
-
Traditional Acupuncture Institute, Inc.
-
Traditional Chinese Medicine Clinic
-
Western States Chiropractic College
To identify terms that described distinct massage techniques included in massage therapy
training, Alternative Link queried the Mesilla Valley School of Therapeutic Arts.
The Company then elicited formal reviews of the terms from additional academic institutions,
national associations of practitioners and other SMEs.
With feedback from these SMEs, Alternative Link organized terms under broad categories or
section headings including the following:
-
Laboratory
-
Patient assessment
-
Patient education
-
Modalities and practice specialties
-
Equipment
-
Supplies
Alternative Link also developed "E&M" terms (similar to those used in CPT codes for
Evaluation and Management Services) to reflect practitioner behavior in taking patient
histories and delivering evaluation and management services for CAM.
Alternative Link entered terms and corresponding category designations into a database.
The Company then designed intake forms to collect 1) additional terms missing from the
database, 2) information on average hourly rates, and 3) estimated charges for individual
interventions.
The Company printed out terms from the database and used these in a survey instrument
administered between January and June of 1997.
Survey respondents...
-
checked terms applicable to their healthcare practices;
-
characterized additional approaches to patient assessment;
-
characterized additional approaches to patient education
(e.g., types of advice provided, such as diet, exercise and
other self-care techniques);
-
listed additional practice specialties and modalities;
-
identified relevant new terminology; and
-
indicated time requirements, equipment, supplies and
laboratory services associated with each intervention
(as well as corresponding sources and costs).
On a separate intake form, respondents listed circumstances associated with individual
episodes of care that might influence fees, e.g., standard fee schedules, hourly rates
and extenuating circumstances.
In total, over 120 practitioners of acupuncture, massage therapy, chiropractic, naturopathic
medicine and holistic medicine participated in the above surveys, in 11 separate meetings.
Alternative Link characterized interventions delivered by each practitioner type and
established usual, customary and reasonable (UCR) charges as the 10th to 90th percentile
of reported fees.
In May of 1997, Alternative Link hired an SME on CAM claims management. This, SME, a former
preferred provider organization (PPO) network developer for an insurance company, supplied
non-proprietary information about the contracting, claims anagement and coding systems used
by such companies. The information described non-proprietary aspects of business processes
used to process claims for alternative medicine practitioners in a dozen or more states
between 1995 and 1997. The consultant also supplied non-proprietary information about the
relative values used by such insurers to negotiate fees with CAM providers in those states.
Alternative Link developed models based on this information and sent approximately 1,200
terms and corresponding fee ranges to SMEs for their comments.
SME respondents included...
-
the president of the American Massage Therapy Association,
-
a board member of the National Alliance of Acupuncture and
Oriental Medicine,
-
a board member of the American Preventive Medicine
Association,
-
the executive director (a naturopathic physician and Ph.D.)
of the American Board of Specialties of Alternative Medicine,
-
a naturopathic physician/researcher at Bastyr University,
-
two board members of the American College for the
Advancement of Medicine,
-
a board member of the Foundation for the Advancement of
Innovations in Medicine, and
-
a 12-member board of directors of a Chiropractic
Association in a progressive CAM state.
These SMEs...
-
identified terms addressed in academic training for each
type of licensed practitioner,
-
wrote expanded definitions for each term,
-
identified interventions that required certification or
degrees beyond core training for the profession,
-
checked the validity of fee ranges for each intervention, and
-
checked the validity of hourly fees for each profession.
Alternative Link reviewed the SME feedback and identified overlaps in terms: 1)
similar terms and expanded definitions that had essentially the same meaning,
and 2) similar terms but with different expanded definitions and different meanings.
The Company addressed these issues by 1) rewording definitions to meet multiple
user needs or 2) clarifying terms and expanded definitions. In both cases,
Alternative Link contacted the organizations that did the original review to
verify the appropriateness of the changes.
To develop nursing terms for the ABC code set, Alternative Link worked with the
developers of three nursing terminology systems:
-
Nursing Intervention Classification system (NIC)
-
OMAHA system for community healthcare (OHAMA)
-
Home Health Care Classification system (HHCC)
Alternative Link determined that the nursing terminology development and management processes
were sufficiently controlled to be viewed as an extension of the Company's internal business
processes. The Company also determined that it met or exceeded its own criteria for
establishing legitimacy of terms. With the support of SMEs, Alternative Link refined the
terms for use in ABC codes and designated the terms as o fficial ABC terminology.
To develop terms for midwives, Alternative Link worked with NIC, three in-house SMEs on
midwifery, and an instructor at the National College of Midwifery. Members of the Midwives
Alliance of North America subsequently reviewed the terms for accuracy, precision and appropriateness.
To develop terms for mental health interventions, Alternative Link worked with NIC and HHCC.
An SME provided additional insight on appropriate hierarchical placement of these terms
within ABC codes.
To develop terms for Oriental and western herbs and botanicals, Alternative Link compiled
information from reference materials recommended by nationally certified academic
institutions focused on CAM. In-house experts in homeopathic remedies relied on additional
reference books to develop terms for homeopathic remedies. Alternative Link organized these
interventions by scientific name.
To develop terms for interventions that require training beyond core curricula of nationally
certified academic institutions (e.g., reflexology, guided imagery and non-clinical
hypnotherapy), Alternative Link reviewed recognized certification or continuing education
courses and nationally recognized training standards. The Company then ensured expanded
definitions for the terms made note of the additional training requirements.
Ongoing development of terminology that comprehensively describes interventions of alternative
medicine, nursing and other integrative healthcare is at the core of our efforts and endeavors,
and we encourage users of the ABC codes to help us expand and improve the code set. To request
new terminology and codes, please
click here.
|
|
|
|